Drafting and publication of opinions
Show/hide Sharepoint toolbar
Toggle navigation
Menu
Home
General
Compliance
Concepts
Planning
Examination
Reporting
Financial
Concepts
Planning
Examination
Reporting
Performance
Concepts
Planning
Examination
Reporting
More
Review
Opinion
Tools
How To ?
Page index
Resources
Terms
It looks like your browser does not have JavaScript enabled. Please turn on JavaScript and try again.
Drafting and publication of opinions
Page Content
Drafting and publication of opinions
We follow a standard structure to present our opinions.
It is good practice to publish opinions.
Opinion
Reporting
Ref: 68.100
Principles
We follow a standard structure to present our opinions to speed up preparation of the document and to facilitate understanding by the users.
When feasible, we share a draft of the opinion with the main stakeholder(s) before presenting it for approval.
Opinions are subject to the equivalent quality management procedures applied to performance audits -
supervision, review
and
independent quality review
.
It is good practice to publish opinions for impact and transparency.
Instructions
Drafting the opinion
Draft the opinion using the following standard structure.
Introduction
Set out the reason for the ECA making the opinion by reference to the legal basis, legislative proposal and request from EU Institutions.
When necessary for the purposes of clarity provide brief background information to help readers understand the legislative proposal, including hyperlinks to sources with further detail.
Set out the scope of our opinion and any significant limitations. List any relevant previous ECA reports and opinions.
General observations
If likely to help readers understand our opinion, present general remarks on the legislative proposal and on the opinion.
Specific comments
Organise specific comments to follow the structure of the legislative proposal. Include clear references to the paragraphs on which we provide our comments. For long legislative proposals, consider using non-evaluative sub-headings to help the reader navigate through the text.
Wherever possible, suggest amendments to the legislative proposal to add clarity to the points we raise in our opinion. Present these suggestions and other comments we make in a table. If the table is very large, consider presenting it in an annex to the opinion.
Consultation with the main stakeholder
Share a draft of the opinion with the main stakeholder(s) before presenting it for approval, making it clear that this is an early draft not yet approved. This gives them the opportunity to consider and respond to the main elements of the opinion, and if appropriate, to start taking our suggestions into account. It is also in line with our ‘
no surprises approach
’ and helps our opinions to be of high quality and robust. However, if the deadline for publishing the opinion is extremely short, the issues complex and/or the number of stakeholders high, consider a more limited consultation.
Publication
The chamber concerned can decide on a case-by case-basis
whether to publish opinions
.
It is good practice to publish mandatory opinions.
Non-mandatory opinions and observations on a proposal for legislation may also be published, after consulting the
institution making the request and other institutions concerned
. These institutions have the right to provide a reply, and for that reply to be published. If they provide a reply to be published, set up a formal consultation, analogous to the
adversarial procedure
for special reports, on the draft opinion approved by the chamber.
If considered useful, complement the publication with a user-friendly summary and/or publicity material.
The template for draft opinion on legislative proposal is available in Eurolook.
Related documents
Rules
Art 259(2) FR
Art 11 ECA-RP
Art 57, 71 ECA-IR
Principles
Instructions
Drafting the opinion
Consultation with the main stakeholder
Publication
Last Modified
: 27/04/2023 16:19
Tags
:
‹
›
×